Daemonwolfbooks ([info]daemonwolfbooks) wrote,

3/10 - The Reading Group by Elizabeth Noble (19/07/05)



Audience Aware



Category: Fiction
480 pages, Paperback
ISBN: 0340734701
Publisher: Coronet Books


Inspired/Suggested by: Idle purchase in a charity bookshop.



Heat, January 31, 2004: 'A compelling read, with characters you'll really take to your heart'

I really don't know what was going through my mind when I bought this but I imagine not much. The fact is, I am no judge of whether this is good or bad because I am so outside of its targeted audience. This book is cyncially aimed at women who have been married over a decade with teenaged kids. If you do not fit this model then you are unlikely to remember the names of the characters never mind care for them and their lives. The chunks that deal with the books covered each month don't really bring a lot to the table as critique goes and at 480 pages this book felt like a chore once I hit the 300 page mark. 3/10 since I lost interest in all the characters before the end. I am the wrong person for this and will try to make sure someone who better fits its model gets hold of it soon.

Track the rest of the book's journey.
Tags: ! - books about reading, ! - fiction

  • Post a new comment

    Error

  • 3 comments

[info]myopicmeringue

August 1 2005, 22:10:46 UTC 6 years ago

I hated this book. I am not its target audience either, but I judge it as a crap book anyway! It seemed to me that the underlying message was that the most important thing in life is having children, that you can't find true happiness unless you have children, that those who don't want children are selfish, and those who can't have children are tragic figures to be pitied.

But I am interested to hear what someome who is the target audience would think of it.

[info]lizmopuddy

August 17 2005, 22:18:25 UTC 6 years ago

I am the target audience married 19 years with two kids, and the book was crap. This was my BC review "Each subject probably not touched on enough. Each charcter is not fully closed out, or each book not fully discussed. A bit like the "Love Actually" of literature"

[info]daemonwolfbooks

August 18 2005, 07:46:47 UTC 6 years ago

Harsh but fair, welcome to my journal. :)
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…